Analyzing Competitors' Funnel Discount Strategies: Researching Without Copying

Introduction to Competitive Funnel Analysis

Have you ever wondered how your competitors are able to attract so many customers with their discount offers? Or why their sales seem to spike at certain times of the year? Understanding how other businesses in your market use discounts to attract and keep customers can give you valuable insights for your own business.

Competitive funnel analysis, sometimes called “funnel hacking,” is simply the process of studying how other businesses move customers from first discovering their products to becoming loyal buyers. It’s like being a detective who follows the path that customers take when they shop with your competitors.

When done ethically, this research can help you understand:

How competitors attract new customers with special first-time offers
What discount strategies they use to convince hesitant shoppers
How they encourage repeat purchases after the first sale

According to recent market research, companies that regularly analyze competitors’ strategies are 37% more likely to report year-over-year growth. This isn’t about copying what others do—it’s about learning from the market to create something even better for your customers.

In this article, we’ll walk through how to research competitors’ discount strategies ethically, understand what makes them effective, and use those insights to improve your own approach. By the end, you’ll have a clear roadmap for conducting research that inspires rather than imitates.

Identifying Key Competitors for Discount Strategy Analysis

Before diving into research, you need to know which competitors are worth studying. Not all businesses that seem similar to yours will provide useful insights for your discount strategy.

Think about competitors in two main categories:

Direct vs. Indirect Competitors

Direct competitors sell products or services very similar to yours. For example, if you sell handmade leather wallets online, other handmade wallet sellers would be direct competitors.

Indirect competitors fulfill the same customer needs but with different products. Continuing our example, companies selling digital wallets or phone cases with card holders might be indirect competitors because they solve the same problem (carrying payment methods) differently.

Both types can offer valuable insights on discount strategies, but in different ways. Direct competitors show what discount approaches already work in your exact market, while indirect competitors might reveal innovative discount methods you hadn’t considered.

Creating a Competitive Analysis Matrix

To organize your research, create a simple table that tracks important aspects of each competitor’s discount approach:

Competitor	Price Point	Discount Frequency	Primary Target Audience	Main Discount Types
Competitor A	Premium	Rarely (2-3 times yearly)	Professionals, 30-45	Free gift with purchase
Competitor B	Budget-friendly	Weekly flash sales	Students, 18-24	% off + free shipping

This organization helps you see patterns across your market. You might notice that premium brands offer fewer discounts but make them more substantial, while budget-friendly brands run frequent smaller promotions.

When choosing which competitors to focus on, consider:

Those with similar business size to yours (they likely face similar challenges)
Businesses with overlapping customer segments
Competitors that appear to be growing quickly or have loyal customer bases
Companies with seasonal patterns similar to your business

Start with 3-5 competitors for deep analysis rather than trying to track too many at once. This focused approach will give you more actionable insights without overwhelming you with data.

Now that you know who to research, let’s look at how to map out their entire discount strategy across the customer journey.

Mapping Competitors’ Funnel Stages and Discount Touchpoints

Every customer goes through several stages before making a purchase, and smart businesses offer different types of discounts at each stage. By mapping these discounts throughout the customer journey, you can understand the full strategy behind your competitors’ approaches.

Top-of-Funnel Discount Strategies

These discounts aim to attract new visitors and turn them into leads. Look for how competitors use:

Welcome offers – Do they offer 10% off for new visitors? How do they display this offer?
Email signup incentives – What do they give away to get email addresses? A free guide? A discount code?
Social media exclusive deals – Are they offering special discounts only announced on Instagram or Facebook?

For example, a clothing retailer might offer “15% off your first order when you join our mailing list,” displayed as a popup that appears after 30 seconds on their site. This strategy focuses on building their contact list while providing immediate value to new visitors.

Middle-of-Funnel Approaches

These discounts help convince people who are interested but not yet ready to buy. Watch for:

Cart abandonment recovery – What discount do they offer in follow-up emails when you leave items in your cart?
Limited-time offers – Do they create urgency with countdown timers on their discounts?
Comparison incentives – Do they offer price-matching or “beat any quote” guarantees?

I recently noticed an electronics store that sends a 5% off coupon exactly 24 hours after you abandon a cart, followed by a 10% off offer if you still haven’t purchased after three days. This tiered approach shows they’ve carefully tested what discount levels convert hesitant shoppers.

Bottom-of-Funnel Conversion Tactics

These are the discounts that seal the deal for customers who are almost ready to purchase:

Checkout page offers – Last-minute discounts that appear just before payment
Bundle deals – “Complete the look” or “Frequently bought together” discounts
Free shipping thresholds – “Spend $X more to get free shipping”

Many successful online stores show a progress bar toward free shipping, encouraging customers to add just one more item to their cart. This simple tactic can significantly increase average order value while giving customers the satisfaction of “earning” a benefit.

Post-Purchase Discount Strategies

Smart competitors don’t stop offering discounts after the first purchase. Look for how they encourage repeat business:

Loyalty programs – Points systems, VIP tiers with increasing benefits
Referral discounts – “Give 15%, get 15%” friend referral programs
Win-back campaigns – Special offers sent to customers who haven’t purchased in a while

A beauty brand I analyzed sends a “We miss you” email with a personalized 20% off code exactly 60 days after a customer’s last purchase if they haven’t bought anything since. This precisely timed offer shows they’ve calculated their optimal repurchase window.

As you map these touchpoints, pay attention to how competitors coordinate discounts across different channels. Do their email offers match their social media promotions? Is there consistency in their messaging? The most effective strategies maintain a coherent approach across all platforms while tailoring the specific offers to each channel’s strengths.

Now that we know what to look for, let’s explore how to gather this information ethically.

Research Methods for Ethical Competitive Analysis

Researching competitors’ discount strategies requires a balance between being thorough and remaining ethical. Here are several approaches that keep you on the right side of that line:

Public Information Gathering

Start with information that competitors openly share:

Website exploration – Sign up for their newsletter, browse their products, and note any popup offers
Social media monitoring – Follow their accounts to see what special offers they promote
App store listings – Read descriptions and reviews of their mobile apps for insight into exclusive app discounts

Remember, if information is publicly available, it’s fair game for research. A competitor’s website and social media accounts are designed to be seen by potential customers—including you.

Customer Experience Walkthrough

One of the most valuable research methods is experiencing your competitors’ funnel as a potential customer:

Visit their website as a new user (consider using an incognito browser window)
Sign up for their email list to see what welcome offers they provide
Add products to your cart but don’t complete the purchase
Note what recovery emails or retargeting ads you receive
If relevant to your research, make a small purchase to experience their full funnel

This approach gives you firsthand knowledge of how their discount strategy feels from the customer perspective. I’ve found that actually going through the experience reveals nuances that simply looking at their marketing materials might miss.

Tool-Based Analysis

Several tools can help you track competitors’ discount patterns over time:

Price monitoring tools like Prisync or Wiser that track competitors’ price changes
Email capture services like MailCharts that show you competitors’ email campaigns
Social listening tools that alert you when competitors announce sales

These tools help you identify patterns that might not be obvious from occasional manual checks. For example, you might discover that a competitor consistently offers their deepest discounts on the first Tuesday of each month.

Ethical Boundaries to Respect

While researching competitors, always:

Avoid misrepresentation – Don’t pretend to be someone you’re not to gain information
Respect proprietary information – If information is password-protected or behind a paywall, don’t try to access it inappropriately
Don’t interfere with their business – Never place large orders you don’t intend to complete just to test their process

The goal is to gather insights that inspire your own strategy, not to disrupt their business or steal confidential information. Ask yourself: “Would I be comfortable if a competitor researched my business this way?” If the answer is no, find another approach.

With ethical research methods in place, let’s examine what specific elements of competitors’ discount strategies you should analyze.

Analyzing Competitors’ Discount Strategy Components

Once you’ve gathered information about your competitors’ discount approaches, it’s time to break them down into specific components. This detailed analysis will help you understand not just what they’re doing, but why it might be working.

Discount Types and Structures

Look closely at the format of discounts your competitors offer:

Percentage vs. fixed amount – Do they prefer “20% off” or “$15 off”? At what price points do they switch between these approaches?
Threshold-based offers – Do offers like “Save $20 when you spend $100” appear frequently?
Bundle discounts – Are they using “Buy one, get one 50% off” or “Complete the set and save 15%”?
Free shipping strategies – Is there a consistent free shipping threshold? Does it change during promotions?

The choice between percentage and fixed discounts often reveals strategic thinking. For example, high-priced competitors often use fixed amount discounts (“$50 off”) because percentages would cut too deeply into their margins, while percentage discounts work better for lower-priced items where a fixed amount might not seem significant.

Timing and Frequency Patterns

Understanding when and how often competitors offer discounts tells you a lot about their overall strategy:

Seasonal patterns – Beyond obvious holidays, do they have regular sales cycles?
Day of week/time of day – Do flash sales consistently appear on specific days?
Duration of offers – Are discounts typically available for 24 hours, a weekend, or a full week?

I once tracked a competitor who launched their biggest promotion of the quarter consistently on the last Thursday of each month, suggesting they were timing discounts to coincide with many consumers’ payday. This insight about timing rather than just discount amount was incredibly valuable.

Segmentation and Personalization

Advanced competitors tailor their discount strategies to different customer groups:

New vs. returning customer offers – Are loyal customers rewarded with better discounts?
Geographic targeting – Do international customers receive special shipping deals?
Purchase history influence – Are discounts related to previous buying behavior?

You can test this by creating multiple accounts or using different devices to see if offers change. One effective approach I’ve seen is offering deeper discounts to customers who buy from specific product categories to encourage category expansion. For example, a customer who only buys skincare might receive special offers on makeup to broaden their purchases.

Messaging and Presentation

The way competitors communicate their discounts often reveals their psychological strategy:

Urgency triggers – Do they use countdown timers or “limited quantities available”?
Exclusivity language – Is it a “members-only offer” or a “private sale”?
Value framing – Do they emphasize the percentage off or the final price?

Pay attention to the emotions they’re trying to evoke. A luxury brand might frame discounts as “exclusive access” rather than “sales” to maintain their premium positioning, while a value-focused brand might emphasize the total savings amount prominently.

As you analyze these components, look for consistency and contradictions in their approach. Does their discount strategy align with their overall brand positioning? Inconsistencies might reveal areas where they’re struggling or experimenting, which could represent opportunities for your business.

Now let’s move on to interpreting all this competitive data effectively.

Interpreting Competitor Discount Data Effectively

Collecting information about competitors’ discount strategies is just the first step. The real value comes from interpreting this data to understand what’s working, why it’s working, and how it might apply to your business.

Identifying Patterns and Trends

Look for recurring elements across different competitors:

Are most successful competitors in your space using loyalty programs?
Is there a standard discount percentage that seems common in your industry?
Do certain types of promotions appear consistently at specific times of year?

When multiple competitors use similar approaches, it often indicates these strategies are effective for your specific market. For example, if three of your top competitors all offer birthday discounts, it suggests customers in your market respond well to this personalized approach.

Assessing Effectiveness

While you can’t see competitors’ internal data, you can look for signs that certain strategies are working for them:

Promotion repetition – Discounts they run repeatedly are likely performing well
Customer engagement – Check social media comments on their promotional posts
Stock availability – Do products sell out quickly during certain promotions?

I’ve found that tracking how quickly competitors restock after promotions gives insight into their success. A competitor who consistently sells out during their 30% off promotions and quickly restocks has likely found a sweet spot in their discount strategy.

Recognizing Strategic Intent

Try to understand the business goals behind different discount approaches:

Are they focused on new customer acquisition?
Does their strategy prioritize increasing average order value?
Are they trying to move specific inventory or promote new product lines?

Understanding the “why” behind competitors’ discount strategies helps you evaluate whether similar goals apply to your business. A competitor might be offering deep discounts to clear inventory before a product refresh—a tactic that wouldn’t make sense for your business if you’re not in a similar situation.

Contextualizing with Market Conditions

Always consider how external factors influence the discount strategies you observe:

Economic conditions affecting customer spending
Seasonal fluctuations in your industry
Recent changes in shipping costs or supply chain issues

What works during the holiday shopping season might fail during slower periods. Similarly, discount strategies that worked during economic boom times might be ineffective during downturns. Remember that you’re seeing a snapshot of competitors’ strategies that is influenced by current market conditions.

Distinguishing Tactics from Strategy

Perhaps most importantly, learn to separate surface-level tactics from deeper strategic approaches:

Tactics are the specific offers and promotions (25% off, buy-one-get-one, etc.)
Strategy is the underlying business goal and customer journey design

A competitor might run a flash sale (a tactic), but their strategy might be to convert one-time holiday shoppers into year-round customers. Understanding this distinction helps you adapt their approaches rather than simply copying their specific offers.

With these interpretation guidelines in mind, you’re ready to transform competitive insights into your own original strategy.

Translating Research into Original Strategy

The most valuable part of competitive research is using it to create something better and uniquely suited to your business. Here’s how to transform your insights into an original discount strategy:

Innovation vs. Imitation Framework

For each competitor insight, ask yourself these questions:

What customer need is this discount strategy addressing?
How could we address this same need differently?
What strengths of our business could we leverage to create a better approach?

For example, if competitors offer 10% off for new email subscribers, you might recognize the need (incentivizing email signups) but address it differently by offering a free guide, product sample, or entry into a monthly giveaway instead of a straight discount.

Adaptation to Brand Values and Voice

Always filter competitive insights through your brand identity:

If your brand emphasizes quality, avoid discounts that might cheapen your image
If sustainability is your focus, consider discounts that encourage eco-friendly behaviors
If education is core to your brand, offer discounts tied to product knowledge

A sustainable fashion brand I worked with saw competitors offering standard percentage discounts but created their own approach: customers earned “sustainability credits” for returning packaging or participating in clothing recycling programs. These credits could be applied to future purchases, aligning discounts with brand values.

Competitive Differentiation Opportunities

Look for gaps in competitors’ discount approaches:

Are they neglecting certain customer segments?
Do they ignore specific parts of the customer journey?
Are there frustrations in their discount redemption process?

These gaps represent opportunities for your business. If competitors focus discounts on new customers but offer little for loyalty, you might create a standout loyalty program. If they make customers hunt for promo codes, you could make your discount process seamless and transparent.

Customer-Centric Improvements

Always ask: “How can we make this better for the customer?”

Can you remove friction from the discount redemption process?
Could you provide more flexibility in how discounts are used?
Are there ways to make customers feel special rather than just saving money?

The best discount strategies don’t just save customers money—they make them feel valued. Consider how you might personalize offers beyond what competitors are doing, perhaps by remembering customer preferences or creating customized bundles.

Remember that your goal isn’t to offer the biggest discount, but to create the most compelling value proposition that makes sense for your business model and appeals to your ideal customers.

Now let’s explore how to test and measure the effectiveness of your new approach.

Testing and Measuring Your Adapted Discount Strategies

After developing your improved discount strategy based on competitive research, you need to test it systematically and measure its impact. This data-driven approach ensures you’re genuinely improving upon competitors’ strategies rather than just changing for the sake of being different.

A/B Testing Framework

Start by testing new discount approaches against your current methods:

Test one element at a time (discount amount, timing, presentation, etc.)
Split your audience randomly between the current and new approach
Run tests long enough to achieve statistical significance
Control for external factors like days of the week or seasonal effects

For example, if you’re testing a new cart abandonment discount strategy inspired by competitor research, send your current recovery email to 50% of abandoning customers and your new approach to the other 50%. Track both conversion rates and average order value to determine the true impact.

Performance Metrics

Measure these key indicators when evaluating your discount strategy:

Conversion rate – Percentage of customers who use the discount and complete a purchase
Average order value – How the discount affects total purchase amount
Customer acquisition cost – Cost to acquire customers through discounted channels
Repeat purchase rate – Whether discount-acquired customers become repeat buyers
Profit margin – Overall profitability accounting for discount costs

A common mistake is focusing solely on conversion rate without considering the other metrics. A discount that doubles your conversion rate but cuts your profit margin to unsustainable levels isn’t a success. Similarly, a high conversion rate with no repeat purchases might indicate you’re attracting deal-seekers rather than loyal customers.

Customer Feedback Collection

Complement quantitative data with direct customer input:

Post-purchase surveys about the discount experience
Social media polls comparing your approach to competitors’
Customer service team insights about discount-related questions or concerns

Ask specific questions like “How does our rewards program compare to others you’ve used?” or “Was our discount easy to apply?” This qualitative feedback often reveals improvement opportunities that aren’t apparent in the numbers alone.

Iterative Optimization Process

Create a cycle of continuous improvement:

Implement your adapted strategy based on competitive research
Measure performance against clear benchmarks
Gather customer feedback
Identify strongest and weakest elements
Refine the approach and test again

This iterative process helps you move beyond simply adapting competitors’ strategies to truly optimizing for your specific business and customers. What begins as competitive research eventually evolves into your own data-backed approach.

As you refine your strategy, also watch how competitors respond to your changes. If they begin to adapt elements of your approach, you’ll know you’ve moved from follower to leader in your market.

Case Studies and Examples

Let’s look at some real-world examples of businesses that effectively researched competitors’ discount strategies and created something better:

Successful Ethical Adaptations

Case Study: Online Beauty Retailer

A mid-sized beauty retailer noticed competitors offering standard “percentage off” discounts for email signup, but saw that many of these new subscribers quickly unsubscribed after using their one-time discount. Through customer interviews, they learned that many beauty shoppers were overwhelmed by product choices and worried about buying the wrong items.

Instead of copying the typical discount approach, they created a “Personalized Sample Pack” offer for email signup. New subscribers received a quiz about their beauty preferences, and based on their answers, received free samples with their first order along with a modest discount. This approach:

Addressed the same need (email signup incentive) in a differentiated way
Solved a customer pain point (product selection confusion)
Encouraged first purchases while educating customers
Led to higher conversion rates on full-sized products after sample trials

This retailer now has an email list with 65% higher retention than industry average and converts 40% of sample recipients to full-size purchasers.

Failed Imitation Attempts

Case Study: Small Home Goods Store

A small home goods retailer noticed a major competitor running daily flash sales with deep discounts (40-50% off) on rotating product categories. Seeing the competitor’s social media engagement on these posts, the small retailer decided to directly copy this approach.

The results were disappointing:

Their profit margins couldn’t sustain such deep discounts
They lacked the inventory depth to support daily category promotions
Their smaller audience meant less social sharing and excitement
Regular customers began waiting for items to go on sale, decreasing full-price purchases

After three months of declining profits, they revised their approach. Instead of daily deals, they created a more sustainable “Designer’s Choice” monthly special featuring curated collections at 15-20% off, highlighting the owner’s expertise and unique taste. This approach matched their business scale and brand positioning while still providing regular promotional content.

Industry-Specific Applications

Different industries require different approaches to discount strategy research:

E-commerce Physical Products

In this space, shipping thresholds and bundle discounts often outperform straight percentage discounts. Successful adaptations focus on increasing average order value while covering shipping costs.

SaaS and Subscription Businesses

Extended free trials and tier upgrades typically work better than direct price discounts, which can devalue the ongoing subscription. The most effective strategies focus on demonstrating value before conversion rather than lowering perceived value with discounts.

Service Businesses

Package deals and new client specials tend to be most effective. Since service businesses rely on relationships, the most successful discount strategies focus on getting clients in the door for an initial experience rather than ongoing price reductions.

These industry patterns show why blindly copying competitors without understanding context can lead to poor results. The discount strategies that work for a SaaS business rarely translate directly to a physical product retailer.

Learning from these case studies, we can see that the most successful adaptations involve understanding the why behind competitor strategies rather than simply imitating the what.

Future Trends in Competitive Discount Strategy

The landscape of discount strategies is constantly evolving. As you research competitors and develop your own approach, keep these emerging trends in mind:

AI and Automation Influences

Artificial intelligence is transforming how businesses implement discount strategies:

Dynamic pricing – Real-time price adjustments based on demand, inventory levels, and competitor pricing
Predictive offers – AI-powered systems that determine optimal discount timing and amounts for individual customers
Automated competitive analysis – Tools that continuously monitor competitor pricing and promotions

Forward-thinking businesses are moving beyond static discount schedules to systems that can adapt in real-time. For example, a clothing retailer might automatically adjust discount depths based on inventory levels, weather patterns, and competitive pricing in each geographic market.

Personalization Evolution

The future of discounting is increasingly personal:

Behavior-based offers – Discounts triggered by specific customer actions rather than general promotions
Preference-matched incentives – Offers aligned with individual customer interests and purchase history
Context-aware discounts – Promotions that consider factors like location, device, and time of day

Instead of offering the same 10% off to everyone, advanced businesses are creating unique discount experiences for each customer. A returning customer might receive an offer related to products they’ve previously browsed but not purchased, while a new visitor might see an incentive related to their entry point to the site.

Ethical Discounting Movements

Consumer awareness is driving changes in how discounts are presented:

Transparency in pricing – Clear communication about regular prices vs. discount prices
Sustainable discount models – Moving away from deep discounts that encourage wasteful consumption
Value-aligned promotions – Discounts tied to social or environmental initiatives

Brands are finding that today’s consumers respond well to honest discount approaches. For example, some fashion retailers are replacing constant sales with transparent discussions about their pricing structure and occasional “community appreciation” events rather than creating artificial urgency through never-ending “limited time” offers.

As you research competitors and develop your own strategy, consider how these trends might influence your market in the coming years. The most forward-thinking businesses don’t just respond to current competitive approaches—they anticipate where the market is heading.

Conclusion and Implementation Checklist

Researching competitors’ discount strategies provides valuable insights, but the true value comes from translating this research into a thoughtful approach that works for your unique business and customers. Let’s recap the key takeaways from our exploration:

Key Takeaways Summary

Ethical research is the foundation – Study competitors openly available information and experience their funnel as a customer, but always maintain ethical boundaries
Look beyond the numbers – Understand the psychology and strategy behind competitors’ discount approaches, not just the discount percentages
Map the entire customer journey – Analyze how competitors use different discount strategies at each stage of the funnel
Adapt rather than copy – Use competitive insights as inspiration for your own unique approach aligned with your brand values
Test and measure systematically – Implement changes based on data and continuously refine your strategy

Implementation Roadmap

Ready to put these ideas into practice? Follow this step-by-step implementation guide:

Select 3-5 key competitors to analyze based on business size, customer overlap, and growth patterns
Create a discount touchpoint map showing where and how they offer discounts throughout the customer journey
Experience their funnel firsthand by signing up, browsing, abandoning carts, and potentially making purchases
Analyze their approaches by breaking down discount types, timing, messaging, and targeting strategies
Identify their strengths and weaknesses to find opportunities for differentiation
Develop your adapted strategy that addresses the same customer needs but aligns with your unique business
Implement A/B testing to compare your new approaches against existing methods
Collect both data and customer feedback to measure effectiveness
Refine continuously based on performance metrics and changing market conditions

Remember that developing an effective discount strategy is not a one-time task but an ongoing process of research, innovation, and optimization. The most successful businesses view competitive analysis as a regular practice rather than a periodic project.

Measuring Long-Term Success

As you implement your research-informed discount strategy, evaluate its success against these long-term metrics:

Customer lifetime value – Are discount-acquired customers becoming loyal, high-value customers?
Brand perception – Does your discount approach enhance or detract from your brand positioning?
Market differentiation – Has your approach created meaningful separation from competitors?
Operational sustainability – Can your team effectively manage the discount program long-term?
Profitability impact – Is your overall business more profitable with your refined approach?

The most effective discount strategies don’t just drive short-term sales spikes—they build sustainable business growth by attracting the right customers and encouraging healthy purchasing behaviors.

Have you been trying to manage different discount campaigns across various stages of your funnel? It can quickly become overwhelming to track multiple promotions, timing requirements, and customer segments without the right tools.

If you’re looking for an easier way to implement and manage the discount strategies we’ve discussed, consider installing Growth Suite from the Shopify App Store. This powerful app helps you manage all your discount campaigns from one central dashboard, making it simple to create and track time-limited promotions throughout the customer journey.

With Growth Suite, you can easily implement the competitive insights you’ve gathered by setting up automated discount sequences, testing different approaches, and measuring results—all without complicated technical setup or managing multiple tools.

Ready to transform your discount strategy from a series of disconnected promotions to a cohesive customer journey? Visit the Shopify App Store today to install Growth Suite and take control of your discount campaigns.

Remember, the goal isn’t to offer the biggest discounts in your market—it’s to create the most effective discount strategy that builds your business while delighting your customers. With the right research approach and tools, you can develop discount offers that stand out from competitors while supporting your unique business goals.

How to Grow Shopify Store

Conversion Rate Optimization Guide

Marketing Guide For Shopify

Shopify Time Limited Offer Guide

Mastering Percentage Discounts in Shopify for Maximum Impact

Fixed Amount Discounts on Shopify: When and How to Use Them Effectively

Analyzing Competitors’ Funnel Discount Strategies: Researching Without Copying